Now that everyone has had time to mull over the England test squad to tour New Zealand, I thought it would be a good time to look at it.
The major shock is Matt Prior being dropped. I have to admit, I'm not totally against this decision, but a strange time to do it by the ECB. People were calling for his head after a dreadful series with the bat against India. He keeps his place. He bats well against Sri Lanka. But then gets dropped. Strange Indeed, but the decision has been put on his wicket-keeping ability, which is a bit of a change from the norm for the ECB.
Tim Ambrose spent countless years at Sussex as Prior's number two, never getting a look in, which forced him to move on to Warwickshire. The move has now paid off for him, as he replaces Prior for the tour to New Zealand. And Chairman of Selectors David Graveny has been quoted as saying he will be the wicket-keeper for the test series, ahead of Durham's Phil Mustard. Ambrose had a great season at Edgbaston while Prior was struggling to improve on his debut series against the West Indies.
As I said, I'm not totally against this move, despite it being a big shock. Prior let us down with his wicket-keeping too many times, and although his batting had it's moments, I never saw him as Mr Reliable. Having said this, I feel Ambrose could be another one in a long like of wicket-keepers to come and go. Hopefully I'm wrong, and he sets the world alight in New Zealand with his keeping and batting, but only time will tell.
Experience is a crucial factor in any side, just look at the Australians and Indians! But in Sri Lanka England didn't have the experience when it was needed, which has resulted in the recall of Andrew Strauss. A good move if you ask me, despite a shakey 12 months or so in International cricket, he's what we need at the top of the order, hopefully opening with Vaughan, with Cook moving to three.
Wednesday, January 9, 2008
Tuesday, January 8, 2008
Is this a joke?
Today, umpire Steve Bucknor has been replaced by Billy Bowden for the third test of the Australia India series in Perth. As I stated before, Bucknor made mistakes, but who doesn't? Benson made an equally bad one when giving out Ricky Ponting LBW in the first innings at Sydney.
Bowden is regarded as one of the best umpires, as is Bucknor. So surely that suggests there equally likely to make mistakes. The decisions has been greeted with delight from the Indian Cricket Board, who had threatened to pull out of the tour. What happenes if Bowden makes five poor decisions that cost India another test match? Are they going to buoycot the final test, and are the ICC going to give into their demands again?
Steve Bucknor is being punished when it should be the Indian Cricket Board for suspending the series. I understand India got a rough deal, and sympathise with them to an extent. But they have acted unprofessionally and this latest movement by the ICC to please them is simply a disgrace.
Bowden is regarded as one of the best umpires, as is Bucknor. So surely that suggests there equally likely to make mistakes. The decisions has been greeted with delight from the Indian Cricket Board, who had threatened to pull out of the tour. What happenes if Bowden makes five poor decisions that cost India another test match? Are they going to buoycot the final test, and are the ICC going to give into their demands again?
Steve Bucknor is being punished when it should be the Indian Cricket Board for suspending the series. I understand India got a rough deal, and sympathise with them to an extent. But they have acted unprofessionally and this latest movement by the ICC to please them is simply a disgrace.
Monday, January 7, 2008
A New Era
Welcome to the start of Twelfth Man, James Hendry's blog on the world of cricket. We start with a pressing issue; the 'racism' row between Australia and India. Sparked off way before the current incident surrounding Harbhajan Singh.
It all started in October with the one-day series between the two nations. Australia went on to win 4-2 in a hottely contested series. However, the series was mared by racist slur from some sections of the Indian crowd towards Australia's Andrew Symonds (a fantastic cricketer, if you don't mind me saying!).
Nothing seemed to happen bar mild warnings from Cricket Australia and the BCCI, but the situation has escalated earlier this week, when Harbhajan was deemed to have called Symonds a "monkey". The spinner who has bowled very well in the opening two tests (removing Ponting three times) was hit with a ban, which has caused India to suspend the tour in protest. There has also been angry reactions to umpiring decisions by fans.
But why have they suspended the tour? Is it a matter of principal? If the Umpires and match referee Mike Proctor have found Harbhajan guilty, they should take it, and get on with the series. They're not going to change their minds now the Indians have suspended the tour. It just seems a bit unintellegent and pety. It's throwing the game into disripute and I for one hope India reverse their decision and resume this tour.
Secondly, why the over the top reaction to bad umpiring decisions?! Every team gets rough decisions, and yes they can affect the result of a match, but these things have a way of evening themselves out. Dravid was given out wrongly, a bad decision. But these umpires have a split second to decide, they don't have the technology. Harbhajan himself got a wicket in his favour from a poor umpiring decision by Mark Benson.
I wouldn't bet against more poor umpiring decision in the third test at Perth (if the tour resumes!!). Maybe this time the decisions will weigh in India's favour, and they can create an exciting fourth and final test.
It all started in October with the one-day series between the two nations. Australia went on to win 4-2 in a hottely contested series. However, the series was mared by racist slur from some sections of the Indian crowd towards Australia's Andrew Symonds (a fantastic cricketer, if you don't mind me saying!).
Nothing seemed to happen bar mild warnings from Cricket Australia and the BCCI, but the situation has escalated earlier this week, when Harbhajan was deemed to have called Symonds a "monkey". The spinner who has bowled very well in the opening two tests (removing Ponting three times) was hit with a ban, which has caused India to suspend the tour in protest. There has also been angry reactions to umpiring decisions by fans.
But why have they suspended the tour? Is it a matter of principal? If the Umpires and match referee Mike Proctor have found Harbhajan guilty, they should take it, and get on with the series. They're not going to change their minds now the Indians have suspended the tour. It just seems a bit unintellegent and pety. It's throwing the game into disripute and I for one hope India reverse their decision and resume this tour.
Secondly, why the over the top reaction to bad umpiring decisions?! Every team gets rough decisions, and yes they can affect the result of a match, but these things have a way of evening themselves out. Dravid was given out wrongly, a bad decision. But these umpires have a split second to decide, they don't have the technology. Harbhajan himself got a wicket in his favour from a poor umpiring decision by Mark Benson.
I wouldn't bet against more poor umpiring decision in the third test at Perth (if the tour resumes!!). Maybe this time the decisions will weigh in India's favour, and they can create an exciting fourth and final test.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)